Statement
When designers relinquish direct control over the visual composition and instead design a set of rules and structures, will the graphics generate meaning through the participants’ actions?
I explored this question by building a maze-generating tool. In the first week, acting as the creator of the rules governing graphic changes, I conducted 100 visual iterations. However, since all 100 images shared the same visual DNA (six basic shapes), the differences in the results stemmed solely from the paths taken. In the second week, I opened the rules themselves to the user: shapes, mappings, materials, and blending modes could all be customized, while the walking process was recorded as a replayable animation—the rhythms of pauses, hesitations, and accelerations were preserved as behavioral fingerprints.
As a purpose-driven structure, the maze forces players to shift their attention from “what result do I want” to “where do I go next.” This project does not judge the rightness or wrongness of a path; it makes the process itself visible. I seek to demonstrate that design is not merely about controlling the outcome; designing a framework that allows the process to take shape is, in itself, a form of creation.
Annotated Bibliography
Reference 1
Course Reading List – Situating the project in a broader discourse
(a) Academic Citation:
Blauvelt, A., Maurer, L., Paulus, E., Puckey, J. and Wouters, R. (2013) Conditional Design Workbook. Amsterdam: Valiz, pp. ii–xiv.
(b) Sampled Detail:
“Design conditions using intelligible rules. Avoid arbitrary randomness. Difference should have a reason. Use rules as constraints. Constraints sharpen the perspective on the process and stimulate play within the limitations.”
(c) Statement (how this detail contributes to my understanding):
The Conditional Design Manifesto states “avoid arbitrary randomness. Difference should have a reason.” This methodology guided the construction and iteration of my Graphic Maze. In Week 1, the maze game rules were fixed (↑ = stretch, ← = split); within these limited operations, the final graphic varied according to differences in walking path. Week 2 expanded the scope of the rules — making the rules themselves user-configurable: users select a mapping for each of the four directional keys from an action menu (rotate, stretch, hue shift, jitter, etc.), then choose their own shape combinations, blend modes, and textures from a shape library. This means the second week’s iteration operates on a dual level — the rule level (different users select different mapping combinations) and the path level (different walking behaviour under the same rules), allowing individual intuition and experience to manifest more distinctly within the maze’s rule framework.
The Manifesto also states “the process produces formations rather than forms.” The second week’s maze game records each walk as sound and animation: when the maze ends, the webpage plays back not a final image but the walking process itself — pauses, backtracking, even walking speed are all preserved in the animation’s rhythm. The final output is no longer a static form but a dynamic formation.
Reference 2
Course Reading List – Situating the project in a broader discourse
(a) Academic Citation:
Barthes, R. (1977) ‘Death of the Author’, Image, Music, Text. London: Fontana Press, pp. 143–148.
(b) Sampled Detail:
“The birth of the reader must be at the cost of the death of the Author.”
(c) Statement (how this detail contributes to my understanding):
Barthes declared the “death of the Author” — a text’s meaning is determined not by the author’s intention but by the reader’s reception. In my project, “the death of the Author” occurs twice. The first time, in Week 1: I designed a fixed rule system but relinquished control over composition — the visual outcomes of 100 images were entirely determined by the walker’s path. I, as “author of the image,” died; the walker became the “reader/writer.”
The second time, in Week 2: I surrendered even the authority over the rules themselves — users now choose their own shape combinations, colours, sizes, blend modes, and textures. I, as “author of the rules,” also died, leaving only a framework designer. Barthes writes “the birth of the reader must be at the cost of the death of the Author” (p.148); in Week 2 this “birth” is more complete — users are not only executing (walking the maze) but also designing (configuring rules), and the final playback animation turns their walking process into a “text” viewable by a third party. The person watching the playback becomes yet another layer of “reader.” The author’s position keeps receding; the reader’s role keeps expanding — from walker to rule-maker to viewer, each layer produces new meaning.
Reference 3
Topic-related – Specifically related to the project’s theme (how rule variation within a fixed framework produces difference)
(a) Academic Citation:
Queneau, R. (1998) Exercises in Style. London: John Calder. [1947], pp. 9–16, 19–26.
(b) Sampled Detail:
“What particularly struck Queneau about this piece was that, although based on a rather slight theme, its variations proliferated almost to infinity.”
(c) Statement (how this detail contributes to my understanding):
Queneau took an utterly unremarkable bus anecdote — a man has a minor altercation with another passenger, then two hours later is seen at a station being advised to replace a button on his overcoat — and, by changing the rules of telling (style), generated 99 radically different texts: telegraphic, metaphorical, retrograde, olfactory, mathematical. His inspiration came from Bach’s Art of the Fugue: a simple theme whose variations “proliferated almost to infinity.”
This maps directly onto the structure of my maze project: the maze framework is “the unchanging story,” the user-configured rule set (shape combination, directional mapping, blend mode, texture) is “the style of telling,” and each walk’s generated graphic and animation is “a new version.” Queneau’s experiment proves one thing: the source of difference lies not in the content itself but in the rules applied to the content. The visual gap between his 99 styles is far greater than the gap between 99 retellings of the same story — because what he changed was structural (grammar, perspective, rhetorical strategy), not surface-level (word choice, phrasing). This corresponds to my transition from Week 1 to Week 2: Week 1’s 100 iterations changed only the path (surface level), resulting in high visual similarity; Week 2 opened the rules themselves to users (structural level), and difference naturally increased.
As a co-founder of Oulipo (Ouvroir de littérature potentielle), Queneau’s core methodology is “constraint breeds creativity” — under strict formal limitations, creators are forced to invent new modes of expression. The maze walls are exactly this kind of constraint: you cannot pass through walls; you must choose among limited forks. It is precisely this constraint that gives each step its weight, making the final output not random but structured.
Reference 4
Medium/Method-related – Specifically related to the project’s medium or method
(a) Academic Citation:
Reas, C. (2010) Process Compendium 2004–2010. Berlin: Gallery [DAM].
(b) Sampled Detail:
“An Element is a simple machine that is comprised of a Form and one or more Behaviors. A Process defines an environment for Elements and determines how the relationships between the Elements are visualized.”
(c) Statement (how this detail contributes to my understanding):
Casey Reas’s Element–Behavior–Process framework maps directly onto my project’s methodology. In Week 1, this mapping was fixed: six basic shapes were Elements, four directional transforms were Behaviors, and the maze was the Process environment. But Week 2’s customisation system introduced a critical shift: users no longer merely execute within a preset Process — they create their own. They select Elements from the shape library (circle, square, triangle, diamond, star, hexagon, line, spiral, etc. in any combination), configure Behaviors from the action menu (rotate, stretch, hue shift, split, pulse, etc.), and choose textures and blend modes to determine the visual relationships between Elements. Each user effectively defines a unique Process.
Reas argues that the rules themselves are the artwork — an instruction does not point to a single image but opens a space of infinite variations. My system pushes this logic one step further: difference arises not only from different runs under the same rule set, but from each user defining a different rule set altogether. At the same time, Reas’s systems are autonomous — once the rules are set, the algorithm runs independently and the human steps away; my system demands that the person makes real-time choices inside the maze, each step an irreversible decision. The playback animation faithfully preserves the traces of this participation: pauses, accelerations, hesitations — rhythms that no algorithm can generate. They are behavioural fingerprints, and they are what this iterative experiment is truly trying to record.
Reference 5
Critical Position – Demonstrating a critical position in context of the project’s topic, medium, or method
(a) Academic Citation:
Gerstner, K. (1964) Designing Programmes. Zurich: Arthur Niggli. (Reissued 2007 by Lars Müller Publishers.)
(b) Sampled Detail:
“The difficulty is: to find the balance, the maximum of conformity to a rule with the maximum of freedom. Or: the maximum of constants with the greatest possible variability.”
(c) Statement (how this detail contributes to my understanding):
Gerstner’s central question — the balance between “the maximum of conformity to a rule with the maximum of freedom” — runs through both weeks of my iteration. Week 1 tutor feedback noted that the 100 iterations showed excessive visual similarity. Diagnosed through Gerstner’s framework: the problem was that Week 1’s programme had too many constants (fixed six shapes, fixed four mappings, fixed lighten blend mode) and only one variable (the path), causing “conformity” to overwhelm “variability.”
The Week 2 iteration directly addressed this diagnosis — turning most of the programme’s constants into user-selectable variables. Shape combinations, directional mappings, blend modes, textures, backgrounds, and text overlays are all open to user configuration. The framework (maze structure + directional keys + canvas) remains constant; the rule content becomes variable. This is a new realisation of what Gerstner called “the maximum of constants with the greatest possible variability.”
But Gerstner’s framework also poses a new critique of Week 2: he wanted a programme that “makes the bad difficult and the good easy.” My system makes no such distinction — all configuration combinations and all walking paths are treated as equivalent. Is this design openness, or an abdication of “design judgment”? Gerstner’s programme is optimising; mine is neutral. This neutrality may itself be my project’s critical position: the system does not judge actions as right or wrong — it simply makes the process visible.
Reference 6
Wild Card – Cross-media connection: from textile to code, path choices within grid constraints
(a) Academic Citation:
Albers, A. (1965) On Weaving. Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press. (Reissued 2017 by Princeton University Press.)
(b) Sampled Detail:
“Being restricted to the use of thread forced me to find a way of dealing with form that resulted from the characteristics of this material. That was a tremendous help to me, as I think it probably can be to anybody, as long as you, at the same time, are concerned with breaking through it.”
(c) Statement (how this detail contributes to my understanding):
Anni Albers treated the loom’s grid constraint as both a “railing” and a creative starting point — an attitude that mirrors my use of the maze exactly. Weaving and my project are structurally parallel: the orthogonal relationship of warp and weft corresponds to the maze’s horizontal and vertical passages; the weaver’s shuttle choices at each row correspond to directional choices at each fork; the textile’s pattern is an accumulation of paths, just as my graphic is an accumulation of walking.
In Week 2, Albers’s insight becomes more concrete. She said a weaver “must think structurally instead of simply designing the patterns that appear on the surface” — the process of users configuring rules in Week 2 is exactly this kind of “structural thinking”: choosing which shapes, which blend mode, which action each direction triggers. These decisions constitute the “threading pattern” of the textile. Different users’ configurations are like different threading patterns; the same loom (maze framework) produces entirely different fabrics. Critics have described Albers’s textiles as “programmed images” — before the computer existed, the loom itself was a programming device. My project relocates this ancient “path-choice-within-a-grid” from physical fibre to digital canvas, and Week 2 goes further — not only is the path selectable, but the “programming language” itself (the rule set) can be redefined by the user. From the 19th-century Jacquard loom to 21st-century creative coding, path choice under grid constraint remains the fundamental mechanism for producing visual diversity.
Leave a Reply