The core of this project statement is to borrow the method from Raymond Queneau’s Exercises in Style —retelling the same story in multiple styles—to articulate and practically demonstrate Michael Rock’s core argument. This argument posits that in design, form, style, and treatment are themselves meaning, not just passive containers for content. By treating Rock’s “argument” as the fixed “story” and filtering it through Queneau’s “styles,” the project demonstrates how the how (form) actively defines and creates the what (content), thereby proving the thesis that “form is content”.
1. Notation (⊙o⊙)?
(Objective, matter-of-fact style )
In the D360 bus (the design world), in the rush hour. A chap of about 26 (“Form”), felt hat with a cord instead of a ribbon, neck too long.
People getting off. The chap “Form” gets annoyed with one of the men standing next to him (“Content”). “Content” accuses “Form” of just being a container and jostling him every time anyone (an audience) goes past.
“Form,” with a snivelling tone which is meant to be aggressive, says that he himself is the meaning. When he sees a vacant seat (the project’s core) he throws himself on to it.
Two hours later, I meet him (“Form”) in the Cour de Rome, in front of the gare Saint-Lazare. He’s with a friend (“Structure”) who’s saying: “You ought to remember, our content is, perpetually, Design itself.”.
2. Litotes (o_ _)ノ
(The style of intentional understatement )
Some of us (designers) were travelling together. A young man, who didn’t look very intelligent (“Content”), spoke to the man next to him (“Form”) for a few moments, claiming he was the main point.
Then “Form” went and sat down (in the center of meaning).
Two hours later I met him (“Form”) again; he was with a friend and was talking about “design itself being the content.”.
3. Metaphorically (o|o)
(The style of full metaphor )
In the centre of the day, tossed among the shoal of travelling sardines (projects) in a coleopter with a big white carapac, a chicken with a long, featherless neck (“Content”) suddenly harangued one, a peace-abiding one (“Form”), of their number, claiming to be the source.
Then, attracted by a void (the design process), the fledgling (“Form”) precipitated itself thereunto (into the center of meaning).
In a bleak, urban desert, I saw it again that selfsame day, offering a cup of (meaning) offered by a lowly button (style). “Our content is design itself,” it said.
4. Retrograde (^///^)
(The style of reverse chronology )
“Our content is, perpetually, Design itself,” his friend (“Structure”) told him (“Form”).
I met him in the middle of the Cour de Rome, after having left him (“Form”) rushing avidly towards a seat (the center of meaning). He (“Form”) had just protested against being pushed by another passenger (“Content”), who [Content] said that he should be the main point every time anyone got off.
This strong young man “Form” was the wearer of a ridiculous (and meaningful) hat (style).
This took place on the platform of an S bus (the design world) which was full that particular midday.
5. Surprises (⊙ˍ⊙)
(The style full of exclamation and hyperbole )
How tightly packed in we were on that bus platform (the design industry)!
And how ridiculous that “Content” looked! What was he doing?
Well, if he wasn’t actually trying to pick a quarrel with that chap “Form”, who—so “Content” claimed!—was just a container!
And then “Form” didn’t find anything better to do than to rush off and grab a seat (the center of meaning) which had become free! Instead of leaving it for “Content”.
Two hours after, guess whom I met in front of the gare Saint-Lazare, That “Form” fellow!
Being given some sartorial advice, By a friend (“Structure”). “He’s right!” the friend yelled, “Our content is Design itself!”
You’d never believe it.
Raymond Queneau, excerpts from Exercises in Style, [1947] 1998
Michael Rock, ‘Designer as Author’ and ‘Fuck Content’, Multiple Signatures: On Designers, Authors, Readers and Users, [1996] [2009] 2013