Methods of contextualing

WRITTEN RESPONSE

Working with UAL’s food procurement data forced me to confront a tension I hadn’t previously articulated: the gap between data being available and data being understood. The unit kgCO2e/£ is technically precise but experientially hollow — it asks nothing of the reader emotionally, and therefore asks nothing of them practically.

By choosing to reframe this data through the format of a supermarket promotional leaflet, our group placed carbon emissions within a visual language that people already know how to read. Scaling product imagery proportionally to carbon output — and satirising the promotional logic of “best deal” to foreground high-emission items — revealed how persuasion itself is a design tool, not merely an ethical liability. The leaflet doesn’t merely inform; it implicates the reader in a system of consumption they may not have questioned before.

This process has moved me away from being a neutral translator of data toward being a design practitioner who makes active rhetorical choices. Within the UAL Net Zero plan, I now understand food procurement not merely as a logistical footnote, but as a site where meaning is contested — and where environmental data only becomes truly legible when it is made local, relatable, and slightly uncomfortable.


Drucker, J. (2014). Graphesis: Visual Knowledge Production and Representation. Harvard University Press, pp.8–9.

Available at: https://peterahall.com/mapping/Drucker_graphesis_2011.pdf [Accessed Feb. 2026].

Drucker argues on these pages that visual epistemology must be understood at the intersection of humanistic and scientific knowledge — and that the conventions governing information graphics carry intellectual assumptions that are rarely made explicit. Her observation that graphics are “economical, efficient, and offer a way to grasp complex relations in an immediately legible form” initially seems to validate our project’s aim of making carbon data more accessible. But the more pressing challenge she identifies is that the methods by which graphics are composed — what is measured, and how — are governed by statistical disciplines that shape interpretation before the reader even arrives. This reframed how our group understood kgCO2e/£: not as a neutral input awaiting better visualisation, but as a unit already embedded in specific epistemological authority. The supermarket leaflet format was, in part, a response to this — by placing carbon data within the rhetorical conventions of commercial promotion rather than scientific reporting, we were shifting its interpretive ground, making visible the constructed nature of any graphic claim to objectivity.


Kyong Chun, W.H. (2017). ‘On Patterns and Proxies’. E-flux Architecture.

Available at: https://www.e-flux.com/architecture/accumulation/212275/on-patterns-and-proxies.

Kyong Chun’s central argument — that proxies are “necessary and inadequate,” that they “reduce uncertainty even as they introduce it” — reframed how our group understood the unit kgCO2e/£. Like Mann’s hockey stick, which Kyong Chun analyses at length, a carbon emissions figure attached to a food product is a proxy: it compresses vast, uneven, and spatially distributed processes into a single legible number. Her analysis of how the hockey stick was simultaneously used to convince and to generate denial — that “the same image can foster both belief and mistrust” — was directly unsettling for our project. It warned us that a clearer or more compelling graphic does not guarantee the response we intend. More productively, her observation that Mann ultimately “embraced rather than eschewed images,” moving toward satire and political engagement, gave critical backing to our decision to adopt a satirical supermarket leaflet format. Rather than presenting carbon data as neutral scientific fact, we chose a form that makes its own rhetorical position explicit — acknowledging, as Kyong Chun insists, that proxies “make politics necessary.”


2.Texts outside the reading list

Doyle, J. (2016). Mediating Climate Change. Routledge.

Available at: https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/mono/10.4324/9781315594583/mediating-climate-change-julie-doyle

Doyle identifies the persistent gap between public awareness of climate change and collective action as a consequence of how climate change has historically been framed — mediated predominantly through numerical systems and scientific representations that, despite their intended transparency, render it a distant phenomenon rather than a personally relevant social condition. This argument challenged our group’s initial approach to the food procurement data, where we had assumed that clearer visualisation would naturally produce greater engagement. In response, our project deliberately resists this normative environmental framing by situating UAL’s carbon emissions data within the familiar visual language of supermarket promotion. By translating procurement figures into the everyday context of food consumption, the leaflet reframes climate change not as an abstract environmental statistic but as a tangible reality perpetuated through individual daily choices. Doyle’s framework thus helped us articulate why the satirical format was not merely a stylistic decision, but a critical one — challenging the ambiguity and distance that dominant modes of climate communication have historically produced.


Marshall, G. (2014). Don’t Even Think About It: Why Our Brains Are Wired to Ignore Climate Change. New York: Bloomsbury. Chapter 9: ‘Inside the Elephant – Why We Keep Searching for Enemies’.

Available at: 

https://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/ual/reader.action?docID=5235993&c=RVBVQg&ppg=48

Marshall argues that climate change communication frequently gravitates toward narratives of individual behaviour change because they are psychologically manageable and politically non-confrontational — and that the more common enemy narrative, which positions one group against another, ultimately distracts from the more productive work of building “cooperation, mutual interests, and our common humanity.” This chapter introduced a productive tension into our project’s design logic. Our supermarket leaflet, by satirising promotional culture and foregrounding the carbon cost of individual consumer choices, risks doing precisely what Marshall warns against: placing accountability squarely on the customer, casting them as the antagonist in the story of environmental damage, while leaving food producers, retailers, and policymakers largely outside the frame of responsibility. Marshall’s analysis pushed me to question whether our satirical format, however critically intended, inadvertently reproduces the individualising tendencies of mainstream climate communication — and whether a more generative design might have found ways to implicate the system rather than the consumer alone.


3.Design practices/projects:

Matilda, A. (2019). Carbon Footprint. [online] Available at: https://adamatilda.com/carbon-footprint [Accessed Feb. 2026].

Matilda’s three-stage campaign — Learn, Choose, Track — operates within a fundamentally optimistic and frictionless design logic: information is made approachable through “positive wording, vibrant colours, and simple illustrations,” and behaviour change is framed as guilt-free and effortless. Engaging with this project helped our group locate our own work in relation to a broader spectrum of climate communication strategies. Where Matilda’s project prioritises accessibility and consumer motivation, avoiding anything that might feel confrontational, our supermarket leaflet deliberately introduces discomfort — using the language of promotion satirically to implicate the reader rather than reassure them. Her use of the grocery store as the primary site of intervention was directly generative for us: it confirmed that the point of purchase is where carbon data can be most meaningfully encountered, and informed our decision to root our visualisations within the visual conventions of supermarket print media rather than in an educational or institutional register. Matilda’s acknowledgement that “some consumers may feel attacked” by carbon footprint infographics became a productive tension our group accepted as a necessary condition of critical literacy, rather than something to be designed around.


Rambaud-Measson, C. (2022). Carbon FoodPrint. [online] Available at: https://canlportfolio.com/portfolio/carbon-foodprint [Accessed Feb. 2026].

Rambaud-Measson’s core design move — translating CO2 figures into car-driven miles to make carbon data “tangible” rather than numerical — directly informed our group’s thinking about the unit kgCO2e/£. Her recognition that “unlike money, we are not used to thinking about carbon costs” identified the same problem we encountered with UAL’s procurement data: the unit is technically present but experientially absent from consumer decision-making. Her approach of using food packaging as the design surface also inspired our choice of the supermarket leaflet format — both projects embed carbon information within visual conventions that consumers already navigate daily, rather than asking them to engage with a separate information system. However, where Carbon FoodPrint translates data through equivalence — converting one invisible measure into a more familiar one — our project uses scale directly: product imagery on the leaflet is sized proportionally to carbon output, making the disparity between categories immediately visible without requiring conversion. Rambaud-Measson’s project represents the constructive end of the design spectrum, and it was precisely by identifying the limits of her approach that our group found the critical edge of our own.